Evaluation of bowel management program on quality of life in children with fecal incontinence
Zohreh Shahba, Bahareh Ahmadi, Saeedg Haji Bandeh, Mehrdad Hosseinpour
Departement of Pediatric Surgery, Imam Hossein Children Hospital, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
|Date of Submission||21-Jul-2020|
|Date of Decision||19-Jun-2021|
|Date of Acceptance||02-Oct-2021|
|Date of Web Publication||30-Aug-2022|
Dr. Mehrdad Hosseinpour
Imam Hossein Children Hospital, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Fecal incontinence (FI) is a common disorder that affects the psychological, social, and mental aspects in children. It was showed that the quality of life (QoL) in children with FI was in low level. Bowel management program (BMP) is one of the most effective and low-cost therapies in selected children with FI, but it has also significant effects on mental functions. This study was conducted to evaluate the impact of BMP on the QoL of children with FI. Materials and Methods: In a case series study, we prospectively included all school-age children suffering from FI who had visited in colorectal follow-up center of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. Patient eligibility included children with FI between 8 and 12 years who were candidate of BMP. The QoL was assessed by Persian version of pediatric QoL (PedsQL) 4.0. Results: In this study, 24 children with FI were studied. Our results showed that total QoL score is significantly different after BMP. The mean score of physical performance before and after BMP was significantly different (P = 0.02). In terms of emotional performance, the mean score of this dimension before and after starting of BMP was significantly different (P = 0.06). In terms of social performance, the mean score of this dimension before and after starting of BMP was significantly different (P = 0.008). Conclusion: BMP is a low-cost and affordable treatment that can have a significant impact on improving the QoL of the child by improving intestinal function.
Keywords: Bowel management program, fecal incontinence, quality of life
|How to cite this article:|
Shahba Z, Ahmadi B, Haji Bandeh S, Hosseinpour M. Evaluation of bowel management program on quality of life in children with fecal incontinence. Adv Biomed Res 2022;11:69
|How to cite this URL:|
Shahba Z, Ahmadi B, Haji Bandeh S, Hosseinpour M. Evaluation of bowel management program on quality of life in children with fecal incontinence. Adv Biomed Res [serial online] 2022 [cited 2022 Sep 30];11:69. Available from: https://www.advbiores.net/text.asp?2022/11/1/69/355231
| Introduction|| |
Fecal incontinence (FI) is a common disorder that affects the psychological, social, and mental aspects in children. Studies show that FI exists in 25% of children with anorectal disorders and in a large percentage of patients with spinal abnormalities and can cause shame, fear, and a decreased self-confidence in the child. It also affects their family negatively as conflicts, distress, and can make interacting with the therapy team. A recent study showed that the quality of life (QoL) in children with FI was in low level. Another study showed that the social and emotional performance of children were impaired with incontinence.
Bowel management program (BMP) is one of the most effective and low-cost therapies in selected children with FI. It is used today in various centers around in the world. Although the main goal of BMP is keeping the child clean for 24 h a day,,, Lombardi et al. showed that it also significant effects on mental functions.
So far, the QoL in children with FI and the effects of BMP on it was not studied in Iran. Therefore, this study was conducted to evaluate the impact of BMP on the QoL of children with FI.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This is a case series study, carried out in the Department of Pediatric Surgery, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences (IUMS), from April 2017 to December 2018. After obtaining approval from hospital ethics committee, we prospectively included all school-age children suffering from FI who had visited in colorectal follow-up center of IUMS. Inform consent was obtained from the parents. The exclusion criteria were unwilling of children/parents to do enema or maintain participating the study and patients whose treatment was carried out by other centers. Patient eligibility included children with FI between 8 and 12 years who were candidate of BMP for at list six months. In the first visit, data such as age, sex, and cause of illness (neurogenic, Imperforate anus), were gathered.
The present questionnaire [Figure 1] was the Persian version of PedsQL designed to measure the QoL of children aged 8–12 years and has 23 questions with 5 options scored in the Likert scale ranged from 0 (always) to 100 (each time). The validity and reliability of the Persian version were established by Mohamadian et al. in 2014. The reliability with Cronbach-alpha was 0.82 and for the subscales were 0.65–0.77.
In addition to total QoL, four subscales were evaluated including physical function, emotional performance, social performance, and academic performance [Table 1].
Regarding to this questionnaire, higher score shows a higher QoL. The score obtained for each subscale is between 0 and 100, if <25, the QoL is low, the score of 25–75 the QoL is average, and a score of 75 and more is high QoL.
Distribution of the data was evaluated by Kolmogorov–Smirnov test. The scores of overall QoL and the subscales before and after BMP were reported as mean ± standard. The scores of subscales were compared through paired t-test for normal and Wilcoxon for nonnormal distributed data. P < 0.05 was considered significant. The children's QOL was assessed before and 3 months after the beginning of BMP.
| Results|| |
In this study, 24 children with FI were studied. Ten (41.7%) were boys and 14 (58.3%) were girls. The mean age of girls was 8.33 ± 1 years (min = 6, max = 12) and the mean age of boys was 8 ± 1.19 years (min = 6, max = 10).
[Table 2] shows changes in the QoL dimensions before and after BMP. Our results showed that total QoL score is significantly different after BMP.
|Table 2: The scores of quality of life and subscales before and after bowel management program|
Click here to view
The mean score of physical performance before and after BMP was 57.44 ± 28.52 and 70.65 ± 21.99, respectively, and it was significantly different (P = 0.02). The mean scores of this performance in girls before starting BMP was 32.58 ± 28.68 (Min = 0, Max = 71.55) and after that was 65.17 ± 21.07 (min = 43.75, max = 96.55). The mean score of this performance in boys before starting BMP was 58.85 ± 39.54 (min = 0, max = 100) and after starting from BMP was 65.10 ± 38.50 (min = 0, max = 1000).
In terms of emotional performance, the mean score of this dimension before and after starting of BMP was 55.00 ± 27.12 and 69.34 ± 23.61, respectively, and it was significantly different (P = 0.06). The mean scores of this performance in girls before starting BMP were 49.28 ± 31.51 (min = 0, max = 90) and after that were 65.17 ± 21.07 (min = 0, max = 90). The mean score of this performance in boys before starting BMP was 49.28 ± 31.51 (min = 0, max = 100) and after starting from BMP was 70.83 ± 36.79 (min = 0, max = 100).
In terms of social performance, the mean score of this dimension before and after starting of BMP was 59.28 ± 28.34 and 77.14 ± 20.58, respectively, and it was significantly different (P = 0.008). The mean scores of this performance in girls before starting BMP were 41.42 ± 32.49 (min = 45, max = 100) and after that were 72.14 ± 26.90 (min = 45, max = 100). The mean score of this performance in boys before starting BMP was 46.66 ± 28.92 (min = 0, max = 80) and after starting from BMP was 70.00 ± 36.27 (min = 0, max = 100).
In terms of educational performance, the mean score of this dimension before and after starting of BMP was 59.15 ± 24.57 and 69.56 ± 23.35, respectively (P = NS). The mean scores of this performance in girls before starting BMP were 39.28 ± 24.73 (min = 0, max = 75) and after that were 48.57 ± 43.08 (min = 0, max = 100). The mean score of this performance in boys before starting BMP was 58.33 ± 32.35 (min = 0, max = 80) and after starting from BMP was 62.50 ± 33.72 (min = 0, max = 90).
| Discussion|| |
FI in children can create fear and embarrassment that reduces child self-esteem. Bongers et al. showed that two-thirds of children with excretory system disorders were afraid of getting a dirty underwear and 70% of children with FI had a fear of getting dirty clothes, and 50% were embarrassed that they have FI. In these children, 37% were angry and <40% believed that they can manage this problem. Previous studies also indicate that anxiety and depression have been observed in these children.,, Not only the child but also parents are distressed and family conflicts occur, which affects the interaction with the treatment team as well as the treatment process and reduces the quality of care and treatment and ultimately, the QoL of the child., The current study showed that in our society, children with FI have a QoL at an average level of 48.18 ± 26.16. Bai et al. also showed that in Quality of life for children with fecal incontinence after surgically corrected anorectal malformation is poor. In another study, Bongers et al. concluded that FI is associated with low social and emotional dimensions.
There are several approaches to managing FI, including sphincteroplasty, colostomy, biofeedback, and sacral nerve stimulation that is either invasive or requires the use of certain devices and tools., Meanwhile, BMP is a noninvasive and low-cost method that does not require a dedicated tool. Our study showed that after applying BMP, the QoL increased to come close to the top (73.8 ± 19.2). Smith et al. also concluded that BMP played a significant role in managing FI. Laura et al. also indicated that BMP not only has significant effects on FI but also on mental functions.
Grano et al. in the United States conducted a study on the QoL of children with FI as well as similar QoL assessment tools (PedsQL) which has the QoL of these children before BMP at a close to the top level (73.8 ± 19.2) and after BMP at a high level (93.5 ± 6.2). It was reported that both studies show the successful effect of BMP on the QoL of children. Despite BMP being successful, there is a significant difference in the QoL scores, observed in the two studies, before and after BMP, in which factors such as the level of cultural facilities of society, lifestyle, and even the adaptability of the child and the family are to be considered effective. Wang et al. in China also saw a significant difference in the QoL of before and after BMP.
The present study shows that the QoL of these children in the physical dimension is at the average level 57.44 ± 28.52, and after BMP, it almost upgraded to the high level (70.65 ± 21.99). Grano et al. also reported that after BMP, an improvement to the physical dimension of the QoL, which matches the current results. Despite this upgrade in the physical dimension, the significant difference between these two studies is in the physical dimension score before BMP. Wang also reported a physical dimension score before BMP at a high level in a study on the effects of BMP on children with FI. Perhaps these differences can be attributed to factors such as living facilities and lifestyle. In general, the physical performance of children and their inability to participate in group and sports activities can be due to abdominal pain and heavy weight because of fecal bulk, whereas BMP will eliminate all these obstacles and keep the child clean for 24 h and as a result, increase the child's ability to participate in group activities, sports games, daily activities, and social communication.
The results of the emotional dimension of this study showed that the performance of children in this dimension before BMP was at an almost average level (55.00 ± 27.12), which has been upgraded to a higher level after BMP (69.34 ± 23.61). In Lombardi study, this dimension before BMP was (67.1 ± 25.4) at a level close to high and after BMP, it was reported at a high level (90.3 ± 13.2). In Wang et al.'s study in China, this dimension before BMP was 36.76 ± 16. 89 at a weak level and after BMP, this dimension was promoted to (63.65 ± 17.56) showing a significant difference.
Due to the psychological conditions of the child and the nightly process and psychological stress caused by the approach in children, favorable conditions regarding this dimension have not been reported in children.
The study showed that children's performance in the social dimension before BMP was (59.28 ± 28.34) at an almost low level and after BMP (77.14 ± 20.58) was promoted to an almost excellent level that corresponds to the results of Wang and Grano. There was a huge difference between the QoL scores before and after BMP was performed. In both studies, the effect of BMP on children's social performance is evident, but the more dramatic difference is that in our country, children had a moderate social performance before BMP, which can be attributed to the inability of children to participate in group games, engaging in sports activities, resulting in fear and embarrassment from being rejected by friends and classmates because of the bad smell caused by FI, their physical weakness and physical inability compared to healthy children. Given our culture, distancing oneself from social activities, the lack of family participation in social affairs, parties and family relationships are very evident after BMP, due to the removal of the problem of FI and the increase in children's self-esteem, the lack of concern for rejection and increased physical capacity over time, we see a significant improvement in this dimension in children in the community.
In the educational dimension of this study, the performance of children before BMP (59.15 ± 24.57) was at moderate level and after BMP (69.56 ± 23.35), it was still moderate, which did not make much difference. In Grano study, the educational dimension had significant improvement after BMP. Due to how children suffering from FI are affected psychologically, problems caused by consecutive absences from school, children before BMP had a moderate level of education that, despite BMP's performance, their educational dimension remained modest and did not change. Fear of dirty clothes at class hours, the need to change clothes, bad smell in class, and getting schoolmates becoming aware of the child's illness, resulting in class dropouts and consecutive absences, and reduced level of education of children with FI. Despite the success of BMP in other dimensions of QoL, the educational dimension is still the lowest of all other dimensions of QoL.
| Conclusion|| |
BMP is a low-cost and affordable treatment that can have a significant impact on improving the QoL of the child by improving intestinal function. Although after BMP, the QoL score was promoted in all four physical, social, emotional, and educational dimensions, the child's educational performance, which is directly related to the psychological and social aspects, did not make any significant progress. It is suggested that these children should be supervised by an educational consultant at school. The limitations of this study include lack of cooperation of children and sometimes, parents to carry out the process.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Rajindrajith S, Devanarayana NM, Benninga MA. Review article: Faecal incontinence in children: Epidemiology, pathophysiology, clinical evaluation and management. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 2013;37:37-48.
Wang Y, Liang H, Wu Q, Zheng H, Liu G, Wen Z, et al.
Bowel management program for pediatric postoperative fecal incontinence in China: A surgeon's experience. Medicine (Baltimore) 2017;96:22.
Bischoff A, Levitt MA, Bauer C, Jackson L, Holder M, Peña A. Treatment of fecal incontinence with a comprehensive bowel management program. J Pediatr Surg 2009;44:1278-83.
Rodriguesa BD, Reisc IG, Coelhoc FM, Buzattib KC. Fecal incontinence and quality of life assessment through questionnaires. J Coloproctol 2017;37:341-8.
Bai Y, Yuan Z, Wang W, Zhao Y, Wang H, Wang W. Quality of life for children with fecal incontinence after surgically corrected anorectal malformation. J Pediatr Surg 2000;35:462-4.
Bongers ME, van Dijk M, Benninga MA, Grootenhuis MA. Health related quality of life in children with constipation-associated fecal incontinence. J Pediatr 2009;154:749-53.
Bischoff A, Tovilla M. A practical approach to the management of pediatric fecal incontinence. Semin Pediatr Surg 2010;19:154-9.
Lombardi L, Garrisi E, Ricco' M, Marchesi F, Casolari E, Gatti C, et al.
Study of intestinal function in anorectal malformations: The role of Bowel management in quality of life. Acta Biomed 2016;87:197-204.
Kovacic K, Sood MR, Mugie S, Di Lorenzo C, Nurko S, Heinz N, et al.
A multicenter study on childhood constipation and fecal incontinence: Effects on quality of life. J Pediatr 2015;166:1482-7.e1.
Mohamadian H, Akbari H, Gilasi H, Gharlipour Z, Moazami A, Aghajani M, Monsef M, Tahvilian H, Azar Abdad A.Validation of Pediatric Quality of Life Questionnaire (PedsQL) in Kashan city. SJIMU 2014;22:10-8.
Hunt RH, Dhaliwal S, Tougas G, Pedro C, Labbé JF, Paul H, et al.
Prevalence, impact and attitudes toward lower gastrointestinal dysmotility and sensory symptoms, and their treatment in Canada: A descriptive study. Can J Gastroenterol 2007;21:31-7.
Olaru C, Diaconescu S, Trandafir L, Gimiga N, Olaru RA, Stefanescu G, et al.
Chronic functional constipation and encopresis in children in relationship with the psychosocial environment. Gastroenterol Res Pract 2016;2016:7828576.
Smith CA, Avansino JR. Commentary on “One-year impact of a bowel management program in treating fecal incontinence in patients with Anorectal malformations”. J Pediatr Surg 2021;56:1694-5.
Grano C, Aminoff D, Lucidi F, Violani C. Long-term disease-specific quality of life in children and adolescent patients with ARM. J Pediatr Surg 2012;47:1317-22.
Muddasani S, Moe A, Semmelrock C, Gilbert CL, Enemuo V, Chiou EH, et al.
Physical therapy for fecal incontinence in children with pelvic floor dyssynergia. J Pediatr 2017;190:74-8.
[Table 1], [Table 2]